For this month’s Retro Cooking, I decided to make a nun’s cake, from the book Anyone Can Bake, published by the Royal Baking Powder Company in 1928.
In all honesty, I was intrigued by the name. A French-Canadian really can’t deny her Catholic-influenced culture! After looking it up, I learned a lot about the type of cake, that came to life in the 18th century and became very common at the turn of the 20th century. I even found a 1923 advertising page explaining the merits of the nun’s cake. According to this, it might have been the “first cake ever made”…which may or may not be true but I like the idea of it!
The recipe was quite simple although finding the rose extract (rose water) was a project. Thankfully, my trusty Buford Highway Farmer’s Market came through once more, in their Eastern European section. The cinnamon extract, on the other hand, had to be replaced by cinnamon powder as I couldn’t find it anywhere.
1928 Nun’s Cake
- 1 cup of butter, softened
- 1.5 cups of powdered sugar
- Yolks of 5 eggs
- Whites of 2 eggs
- 3/4 cup of milk
- 3 cups of pastry flour (I used half all-purpose, half cake flour)
- 2.5 teaspoons of baking powder
- 3 teaspoons of caraway seeds
- 1/4 teaspoon of salt
- 1 teaspoon of rose extract (or rose water)
- 1/2 teaspoon of cinnamon extract (or cinnamon powder)
- Beat the butter until soft and creamy.
- Add the sugar and the yolks. Beat well.
- Stir in the unbeaten egg whites and beat for 1 minute.
- Sift the flour with the baking powder and the salt. Add to the batter alternately with the milk, a little at a time. Mix well but do not over beat.
- Sprinkle in the caraway seeds, cinnamon and rose water. Mix well.
- Pour into a well-greased and floured loaf/cake pan.
- Bake for 1 hour and 40 minutes at 325°F. (***Note: The book said 1h40m but I believe it was fully baked after 1 hour)
The cake flavors turned out really well. I rarely cook with caraway seeds and only tried rose water in Middle Eastern desserts so this was a nice change from the flavors I’m used to. While it was quite surprising to me to find such exotic flavors in a turn-of-the-century American recipe, it certainly made me feel like I need to use these flavoring options more regularly.
The only issue I had with the cake is how dry and hard it was. Part of it was my fault for wanting to stick to the original directions. Cooking a cake for almost two hours seemed like an overkill but I figured there might be a reason for it so, since the cake didn’t seem to burn, I let it cook for the suggested amount of time. It was so dry. I even tried to put cream on it and it still tasted very dry. Later on, I figured that a 1928 oven probably didn’t provide the same heat as its 21st century equivalent. I probably should have baked it for an hour, at most. Live and learn, right? 🙂
8 thoughts on “Retro Cooking: 1928 Nun’s Cake”
Just today I saw liquid cinnamon at Whole Foods.. never saw it before. I was brought up in Ireland where Nun’s cake was well known. As I recall it was basically a sponge cake with caraway seeds. My mother had that same cake book and it was considered very fancy because “ It was from America “ and the decoration of the cakes were elaborate.
That’s so interesting! Thanks for sharing. Now I feel the need to make the cake again and try my hand at elaborate decoration. 😊
I also grew up in Ireland and remember my grandmother making this cake, though she called it Seed Cake. I just tried to recreate it from her 1951 Recipe book. Same result as yours, very dry and hard, even though I ignored the direction in her recipe for 2 hour baking time and took it out after an hour. We used to eat this with butter and cups of tea, now I know why!
Oh that’s so interesting! And it makes me feel a lot better if yours turned out dry too! 🙂 I do feel like it would have been delicious dipped in tea. Now I feel the need to make it again to try that out. Thanks for the feedback! 🙂
Hello, what sized round pan did you bake this in please? Thank you.
Hi! I used a 9-inch springform pan.